Thursday, October 9, 2014

Summary and Response - Blog

          I recently read a blog article that dealt with the topic on whether or not college should be paid. Written by Michael Gonchar, it was titled "Should College Athletes be Paid?" and he opened up with the fact that college football is a business that rakes in billions of dollars, while the coaches are the ones who get paid are receiving large amounts of money on their salaries the players get nothing for what they do. The reason why college athletes receive nothing is because the NCAA has rules that doesn't allow them to earn compensation. Gonchar's point is that with coaches, the schools, and the NCAA enterprise making billions is it really fair for the athletes, the ones who actually generate the billions of dollars in revenue, to be left with nothing in return. Gonchar then leaves off with the question if college athletes should be paid and adds some outside source to back up his argument explaining how the college teams that make to the football bowl events get gifts for making it there. The electronic gifts are the popular ones which can range from iPad Minis to Apple Tvs, all this to show for all the hard work the players have done to get to where they are.

          In this blog I believe Gonchar should've talked more on the issue. He made his point but didn't go further into things that should be done about college athletes being paid. I would've liked to see more on his thoughts and solutions that could resolve the problems that occur. What I did like is how he used some external background knowledge about college athletes receiving some sort of compensation for the hard work they put in, without the use of being paid in cash. I liked how he asked rhetorical questions for the readers which allows them to think about how they feel on this topic. With Gonchar's rhetorical questions it helped me identify his opinion on the topic. Knowing that coaches make the money and the players getting zero compensation he starts to wonder how fair can that be. However, it is not enough to make it a reliable source of for a paper because this source is mainly the external source. I wanted to see more about what he thought with his own knowledge about what is going on and any evidence to back up with what he has to say. If he could include more content on his thoughts then it could be a reliable to source to help write an essay. 

Friday, October 3, 2014

Counterarguement - Why College Athletes Should be Paid

                In an article titled, “Why College Athletes Should be Paid”, the author Tyson Hartnett believes that the NCAA should compensate the student-athletes further than the scholarships that “really only covers the basics”. Tyson also brings up another valid point advocating the payment of athletes is the fact that most athletes are unable to maintain a job or even fit one into their already jam-packed schedules which leaves them with nearly no money to support themselves with. The author supports his view further by referencing the massive paychecks that are dealt out to the coaches and NCAA executives. Hartnett argues that although these collegiate athletes are being assisted financially, however, it is not quite adequate when other associates make hundreds of thousands and sometimes millions for the work that is being done by the athletes. The importance of the main sports programs in colleges is clearly presented throughout the article and highlights the fact that these schools and the other programs would be suffering losses if not for the athletes that participate in the big name sports such as basketball, baseball, and football.

                Although Hartnett is right in his references to the extremely large salaries of NCAA executives and coaches, he fails to see that these payments are not being paid out at every university and only a small number of the big name universities bring in a large amount of revenue from a few of their sports programs. With so many different colleges it would be nearly impossible to set a fair way to compensate all these athletes for their time and still be able to afford everything they currently pay for. However, these athletes are the reason these universities are flourishing and I believe they deserve to be compensated in some form that will benefit everyone instead of small groups, after all, the NCAA is supposed to be nonprofit organization and therefore should provide for the programs and the athletes in them. 

Counterargument to "Let's Start Paying College Athletes"

          In an article I came across called "Let's Start Playing College Athletes," Joe Nocera explains his opinion on whether or not college athletes should be paid. Nocera argues that college athletes should be paid because he knows that the athletes are not stupid, by that he means that the athletes knows that they see their names on jerseys and it is because of them their university is making millions from it.  He states that from college football and basketball alone can generate up to $6 million dollars in revenue and the "labor force," the athletes, that help generate the millions of dollars get nothing in return. If an athlete were to get some earnings then it would have to go through the NCAA to approve it, if not then it would be a violation. Nocera also remarks that even an unapproved burger from the coach or fan is a violation. To him, it's an irrational rule because of the NCAA's strict regulations on what an athlete can or can not receive. As a result Nocera established a plan that consists of five elements. These elements are his thoughts on a way to reward the athletes without simply giving them cash. The first is to offer recruits real athletic contracts just like the professional teams, the second is to create a minimum wage salary for the college sports teams, which includes their scholarship, the third being to offer the athletes scholarships to those who want to go further into their education, the fourth being lifetime health insurance, and the fifth element is to create an organization that represents old and current college athletes. With the NCAA, the coaches, and the university earning millions Nocera believes that his plan is fair instead of the athletes doing all the hard work and receiving nothing.

         In my opinion Nocera's argument that college athletes are basically being unappreciated for all their hard work is something we can agree with. I also like how he establishes a plan that can become realistic, but i can not agree with his plan to create a minimum wage salary for the college sports team. The athletes that do come to play college sports have that privilege to play for the school. These athletes are still students who have also come to college to go further into their education. I do agree that as the NCAA and colleges in this nation make millions the athletes that helped rake in that money aren't being rewarded at all. The other four elements Nocera creates is something i can agree with. Money shouldn't be the focus because what if an athlete wants to get their masters degree or even a doctorates. If that is the case colleges should give their athletes scholarships that are valued more so that it can cover all the fees and expenses and cover the extra years an athlete wants to stay in college to go further into their education. Nocera had a strong argument which can also persuade those that read because it offers realistic solutions. I still can't agree with all of it though. But the solutions he came up with was the strongest part and those who can be persuaded by this would be athletes and the people who have similar opinions on how a college athlete should be rewarded in some way. 

Thursday, October 2, 2014

Summary and Response: Counterargument to "Privilege, not job"

     In a recent article called "Privilege, not job: College athletes shouldn't get paid" by Kate Murphy, Kate argues that it is a privilege for college students to play football, not a job. She states that they shouldn't get paid because she believes being an employee to the university isn't right. College students believe they should get paid because they put in hours of hard work every week. On the other hand, Murphy believes that it is a choice for them to make and it is a privilege to be part of a team that represents your university. She states that those players are on the team because of the coach, on behalf of the university so they shouldn't take it for granted.
     This author makes it a good point when she says that it is a privilege for them to be on the team. But I believe that due to the fact that these athletes are putting in their precious time and dedication into representing the university; they should get paid. Without these athletes, the university and other wide broad series would not make any profit. I didn't find this article persuading because she stated that being an employee to the university is frowned upon, but when it comes down to it, hundreds of college students have jobs on campus. I believe people that don't support college athlete pay would favor this article due to the fact that they don't support it either. They would applaud this article because they most likely agree with her.

Wednesday, October 1, 2014

Summary and response-counterargument- fair play: should college athletes get paid

In the article, Fair play: should college athletes get paid , the author Rebecca Zissou is against paying college athletes and argues that college students are already getting paid, they get a free education, “Student athletes should remember that their main purpose while in school is to get an education, not to get paid”. She not only sets her negative point of view of paying athletes, but as well uses outside resources to prove her point. Zissou also states that "Many top players receive tuition, books, tutoring, housing, meals, clothing, elite coaching, medical care, travel expenses, and career counseling,". This argument that college athletes do not get paid directly but do have expenses paid, is constantly seen throughout the article. The use of strong diction and emotion in Zissou’s writing helps try to persuade her audience, as to why her argument is correct. 
Zissou is correct when she says that athletes do get a free education, but what she fails to bring to light is, that it is rare for all athletes to get a full scholarship and fails to acknowledge how time consuming collegiate sports are.  What many people fail to see is that these college athletes are not only athletes but as well as human beings who still have to find time to eat, sleep, study, and have a social life. I believe that there are other methods such as: not pay athletes directly, but with that extra money that they are gaining, invest that money to the athletics program which will potentially help with recruitment money and better the program, and lastly do not let the NCAA get involved with that money under any circumstances. 

Friday, September 26, 2014

Summary and Response - Academic Article

          In an article I read called "The Myth of the Student-Athlete: The College Athlete vs. Employee," authors Robert and Amy McCormick explained what it means to be an employee of the NCAA. Under the National Labor Regulations Act, the athletes who are a part of the revenue generating NCAA are considered athletes and because they are considered athletes they have the ability to form labor organizations. With this power in their hands, these student-athletes now employees can negotiate the terms of their "employment" and wages. These athletes feel like they do so much for their institution to a point where it is considered even more work than what the employees at the university do. Being considered employees under the conditions of the NLRA, these athletes can determine wages that can be worth more that the athletic scholarships they received.

         Robert and Amy McCormick made a solid point that because of these certain regulations that these student-athletes are now employees but that is something I can't agree with. These athletes come to college to also take their education to the next level and should be considered students. The authors make their point by using the conditions of the NCAA that defines what it would mean to be an employee of the multi-billion dollar industry. Even though these athletes are considered "employees" they are still learning in their classes. These athletes are students of the institution they are taking classes at and no more.

Athlete-student? Diverse examines monetary investment in student-athletes

In Preston Clarks recent work he has demonstrated how student athletes in division 1 colleges have increased graduation rates. Preston goes on giving the percentage that the schools have increased by for example Alabama has increased by "75% and have won 3 of the four national titles." Preston also makes an argument saying these student athletes are putting money back into there schools with graduation rates and there performance. Preston says "it seems to make a bit more sense to then put money back into them."

Preston claim that student athletes should have money put back to them since they bring there campus money is something I strongly agree with. The student athlete is not only participating in the role of an athlete and doing an astonishing job at it the athletes are also bieng students and making the schools graduation rates increase which makes any college look well.